I have the Sparco Stripe Pedals and like them a lot. Only thing is...install was a BITCH. If you are going to try and drill through the stock pedal plates, I recommend getting a diamond tip drill bit. I used a regular bit and ended up breaking one before I got all three pedals installed. I didn't take the rubber pad off of the accelerator (for some reason I couldn't get it off), but the others came off just fine. In terms of having enough surface area to drill for the pedals...it was tight but everything is on their nice and tight.
I am probably going to end up replacing these b/c I am going to redo the color scheme I have in the car. I would recommend these pedals to anyone interested in them...although the install was a pain. The Sparco Grip Pedals are nice as well, so if you are concerned about an easier install, you might want to go with those.
I am probably going to end up ordering these (your choice #1):